Skip to content

How do you choose a fulfilment company? 9 questions before you sign

Choosing a fulfilment partner for your webshop: 9 questions, a scoring table, comparing quotes fairly with the same order profile, and the red flags.

Short answer: Choose a fulfilment company on five things: does it suit your volume and products, does it integrate with your channels, does it meet the delivery time you promise, what does it cost on your own orders, and how tied in are you. Ask three to five companies for a quote with exactly the same order profile and compare the total cost per month, not the price per order. According to FulfilmentMatch, only 25 of 266 fulfilment companies publish a price on their website (November 2026), so without a quote you can almost never compare.

Switching to another fulfilment company takes weeks and a move of your stock. A good choice at the start saves a lot. This article helps you choose between candidates. Which questions to ask in the introductory meeting about integrations, storage and returns is in the checklist of 12 questions.

The 9 questions

1. Does my volume fit their clients?

A company that mainly serves webshops with 10,000 orders a month has little time for your 200. And the other way round, a small team gets stuck on your peak. Ask who their smallest and largest clients are. If you ship little, look at fulfilment with no minimum: 35 companies say they have no minimum order volume.

2. Do they have experience with my products?

Cosmetics with a best-before date, clothing with lots of returns, fragile glass or heavy boxes each need something different. Ask for two clients with similar products.

3. Do they integrate with all my channels?

Your webshop, bol, Amazon and your shipping software must connect without manual work. Ask whether the integration is ready-made or custom, and who maintains it.

4. Do they meet the delivery time I promise?

Look at the cut-off time, weekend shipping and carriers. 44 of the 66 companies that state a cut-off process orders until 22:00 or later. Ask whether that also holds on peak days. More in cut-off time.

5. What does it cost on my own orders?

What counts is not the price per order but the total per month: pick and pack, extra items, packaging, shipping per size and country, storage and returns. How to compare that fairly is below.

6. Where are they?

Distance matters for your suppliers, your own visits and your customers. If you sell a lot in Belgium, a warehouse in Belgium or close to the border can save on shipping. See fulfilment in Belgium.

7. How tied in am I?

Ask about set-up costs, minimum monthly invoice, contract length and notice period, and what it costs to take your stock with you if you leave. 24 companies state on their site that they charge no set-up costs.

8. What do other webshops say?

Read reviews and ask for references you can call yourself. Fulfilment companies with at least five Google reviews have a median score of 4.5 out of 5. A score far below that is a reason to ask more questions. The best-rated are on best fulfilment companies.

9. Who is my contact, and what if it goes wrong?

Ask who you call when there is a problem, how fast they respond and who pays for damage, loss or a wrong shipment. Read the liability section of the terms before you sign.

Scoring table: candidates side by side

Give each candidate a score from 1 to 5 per question and multiply by the weight. Adjust the weights to your own webshop.

Question Weight Company A Company B Company C
1. Volume fits 2
2. Experience with my products 2
3. Integrations 3
4. Delivery time and cut-off 3
5. Total cost per month 3
6. Location 1
7. Contract and notice period 2
8. Reviews and references 2
9. Contact and liability 2
Total (max. 100)

A missing integration or a cut-off that doesn't meet your promise usually rules a company out, however well the rest scores.

Comparing quotes fairly

Quotes often look nothing alike: one charges per order, another per item, a third all-in. You can only compare them if everyone calculates with the same orders. So send every company the same order profile:

What to send Example
Orders per month, and in your busiest month 400, peak 900 in December
Items per order 1.5 on average
Size split 70% letterbox, 30% parcel
Countries 85% Netherlands, 15% Belgium
Number of products and stock 120 products, 3 pallets
Returns 8% of orders
Channels Shopify and bol

Then convert each quote into one number: the total cost per month for this profile, including shipping. Divide by your number of orders and you have a fair price per order. What is typical is covered in What does fulfilment cost?; published prices per company are on compare fulfilment rates.

You can also have that profile built automatically: on FulfilmentMatch you connect your webshop or shipping software, and we read your quantities, sizes and countries. Fulfilment companies then get the same data and you get a cost estimate per company. Start your match.

Red flags

  • Only a price per order, no shipping table. Shipping is usually the biggest item. Without a table per country and size you don't know what you'll pay.
  • A price far below the market without explanation. The median "from" price for pick and pack is €1.75. If a quote is much lower, ask what it leaves out.
  • A long contract with a high minimum. Especially for a growing webshop, monthly cancellation or a short trial period is easier.
  • No portal with real-time stock. Then you email for every question and only see mistakes when customers complain.
  • Vague about peak days. "That always works" is not an answer. Ask what happened around Black Friday last year.
  • No warehouse visit. A good company is happy to show you around.
  • Unclear liability. Who pays for loss or damage, and up to what amount?

Finding candidates

Browse all fulfilment companies with their integrations, carriers and cut-off times, or put two side by side on compare. The best fulfilment companies are ranked by reviews. Small webshop? Start with fulfilment for a small webshop.

Frequently asked questions

How do I choose a fulfilment partner for my webshop?

Check whether the company suits your volume and products, integrates with your channels and meets your delivery time. Then compare three to five quotes on the total monthly cost for the same order profile, and read the contract for minimums and notice period.

What is the best fulfilment company in the Netherlands?

That depends on your orders, products and channels. The best-rated companies are on best fulfilment companies; which ones fit you is shown by a match on your own orders.

How many quotes should I ask for?

Three to five. Fewer gives too little comparison, more takes a lot of time. Send everyone the same order profile.

Where can I compare fulfilment companies?

On FulfilmentMatch you compare 266 fulfilment companies in the Netherlands, Belgium and the German border region on integrations, carriers, cut-off, minimum, price and reviews. Put two side by side on compare.

How long am I tied to a fulfilment contract?

It differs per company: from monthly cancellation to a year or longer. Always ask, together with the cost of taking your stock with you if you leave.

Source: FulfilmentMatch, analysis of 266 fulfilment companies, as of November 2026.

Further reading